Skip to main content

Analysis: Conflict shifts balance of power in the Middle East

By Paula Newton, CNN
updated 9:25 AM EST, Thu November 22, 2012
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • Egyptian President Mohamed Morsy shows value of his leverage with Hamas
  • Hamas gains more influence, leaving Mahmoud Abbas and Fatah on the sidelines
  • Israel's Iron Dome proved its worth by foiling missiles many say came from Iran

Are you affected by the conflict? Share photos and video, but stay safe.

(CNN) -- However crude the calculation, especially amid all the civilian casualties, the winners and losers in the Israel-Gaza conflict are already reshaping political alliances in the Middle East.

Before the last rocket was fired, before U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton announced the cease-fire, there was already a consensus building among stakeholders and analysts that the events of the last week have transformed the fortunes of many in the Middle East.

Egyptian President Mohamed Morsy, clearly underestimated, deftly navigated what is a minefield of competing interests, including those of his own country.

Egypt's role in Israel-Gaza cease-fire
Mitchell: Have to keep trying for peace
Shimon Peres: Work is the best vacation

"For a civilian president in Egypt perceived as a weak leader, he has, much to everyone's surprise, delivered," says Aaron David Miller, a Middle East scholar at the Woodrow Wilson Center.

Egypt and Morsy proved 'pivotal' in Gaza cease-fire talks

Morsy proved he has the leverage necessary to bring Hamas to the table and get its leadership to agree to a cease-fire. Brokering that deal has given him much needed political capital in both the Arab world and the United States.

This was a qualified victory as well for Israel and its tenacious Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Just months before an election, Netanyahu's government targeted and killed Hamas' military leader, Ahmed al-Jaabari. Hundreds of airstrikes on Gaza followed, but the real victory here might have been the combat debut of Iron Dome, the U.S.-funded defense shield that kept dozens of Hamas rockets from hitting Israeli civilians.

Ironically, though, Hamas has emerged emboldened from this conflict and its truce.

"Hamas has emerged stronger, it has consolidated its control over Gaza and it has gained now more legitimacy," explains Miller.

In the eyes of the Palestinian people, the militant leaders of Gaza took on Israel more boldly than ever before, firing rockets farther than ever before. And they may yet manage to get an easing of the Gaza economic blockade if a more comprehensive deal can be reached.

Timeline: Israel-Gaza conflict

Inside Israel's drone system
Israel reacts to cease-fire
PLO reaction to cease-fire

"Look what they accomplished; they, rather than (President Mahmoud) Abbas, has put the Palestinian issue back on the international stage," says Miller.

Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas and his Fatah faction have lost much in this conflict. He was supposed to be the moderate peace broker who could finally forge a new deal with Israel. Now he cannot even claim to speak for all Palestinians and has shown that he has no leverage with Hamas, his archrival.

And then there's Iran, on the outside looking in but always a player when it comes to Hamas. Iran's hand now arguably has been weakened after this episode. The Iron Dome shot hundreds of its missiles out the sky.

While Israel has always accused Iran of smuggling weapons to Hamas through the Egyptian border, Iran today implicitly confirmed it.

"Gaza is under siege, so we cannot help them. The Fajr-5 missiles have not been shipped from Iran. Its technology has been transferred (there) and are being produced quickly," Mohamed Ali Jafari, the head of Iran's Revolutionary Guard, is quoted as saying by the Iranian news agency ISNA.

The question now: If Israel attacks Iran, can Iran still call on Hamas to retaliate with missiles or have they been rendered ineffective with an ever-improving Iron Dome?

In just a matter of days, with one truce, allies and enemies in the region have shifted, and this will certainly affect any future peace negotiations.

How the Middle East has changed since the last Gaza conflict

ADVERTISEMENT
Part of complete coverage on
Israel-Gaza conflict
Are you in the region? Share photos and video of what you are witnessing, but please do not expose yourself or others to a dangerous situation.
Follow CNNArabic for the latest news and analysis from the Middle East and rest of the world.
updated 3:25 PM EST, Sat November 24, 2012
As the dust settles over Gaza and Israel amid relative calm, analysts consider who were the winners and losers from the conflict.
updated 7:40 AM EST, Fri November 23, 2012
Palestinian Authority leaders renewed calls for unity with their Hamas-led rivals after the latest Israel-Gaza conflict, but the fighting may have left Hamas with the upper hand.
The relentless pace of the Israeli airstrike on Gaza gave the country's military time to make a significant dent in the offensive capability of Hamas, the Israeli military said.
updated 9:25 AM EST, Thu November 22, 2012
The brief but bloody Gaza conflict marks a clear wake-up call to both sides on the need to start serious talks beyond the new cease-fire.
updated 9:25 AM EST, Thu November 22, 2012
However crude the calculation, the winners and losers in the Israel-Gaza conflict are already reshaping political alliances in the Middle East.
updated 9:28 AM EST, Thu November 22, 2012
In the background of the drama playing out in Gaza and southern Israel, an election looms. On January 22, Israelis will go to the polls.
updated 6:36 AM EST, Mon November 26, 2012
Four-year-old Yosef lies in a hospital bed with curiosity gleaming in his eyes as he listens to a family friend tell him the age-old story of Jonah and the whale.
updated 2:58 PM EST, Thu November 22, 2012
Egyptian President Mohamed Morsy has won praise for his effort to bring about a cease-fire highlight the delicate balancing act he faces.
updated
Israel and the Palestinian militant group Hamas have been engaged in a bitter, decades-long conflict over Gaza.
updated 1:55 PM EST, Sat November 24, 2012
What is the group, where did it come from and what does it hope to achieve by its rocket attacks on Israeli targets? CNN explains.
ADVERTISEMENT