Skip to main content

Opinion: Author's rant on Catherine 'mean and cheap'

By Robert Jobson, Special to CNN
updated 10:11 AM EST, Tue February 19, 2013
  • Royal correspondent Robert Jobson says Hilary Mantel's attack on Catherine is a venomous publicity stunt
  • People who meet Kate warm to her. She has a winning smile and easy charm, says Robson
  • Robson: I am surprised someone of Mantel's stature has joined in attacking Kate for no reason
  • She has abused her position among the novel-writing elite to launch this attack, he says

Editor's note: Robert Jobson is an award-winning royal correspondent and best-selling royal author, whose books include William & Kate: The Love Story and Harry's War (biography of Prince Harry), both published by John Blake.

London (CNN) -- The venomous attack on the pregnant Duchess of Cambridge by author Hilary Mantel calling her bland and "machine made" is a cheap publicity stunt.

Her remarks saying her impression of our future queen is that of a "jointed doll on which certain rags are hung," with a "plastic smile" and "only purpose being to give birth," is mean spirited in the extreme.

Where does the double Man Booker Prize winner get this impression? Has she ever seen Kate up close or seen her interact with people at home and abroad?

I doubt it very much. If she had she would not have been so rude and inaccurate.

See the Duchess and her royal bump

The darling of the literary establishment I fear is playing publicity seeking games; raising her profile on the back of one of the most famous women on the planet right now.

I respect Hilary Mantel as a writer. I like her books too. But she clearly knows very little about modern princesses -- or duchesses even.

Perhaps all that time writing about Tudor princesses has led her to lose her head -- like so many Tudor heroines.

Mantel has never met the duchess. She has never seen her at work. I have, and I have been impressed by the speed and ease with which she has taken to the job of being a front line royal.

People who meet Kate warm to her. She has a winning smile and easy charm. Yes, she has a long way to go, and is not the new Princess Diana as many in the media are hoping for.

But I think she is slowly but surely carving out a role for herself.

Even Diana took years in the job before growing into the global icon who was so admired before she was taken from us so tragically.

For somebody who is relatively new to royal engagements, Kate has performed with aplomb.

On foreign assignments too, I have seen her at close quarters in Canada, America, Singapore and Borneo. She is professional and warm, complimenting her husband Prince William as they carry out their royal duties together.

Kate and William are a great double act. There is her wifely strength, like the Queen Mother, and as a Queen Consort she does not try to steal the limelight from her husband.

The Palace and Kate have kept a dignified silence over Mantel's rant. It's a wise stance.

I know the team around Kate and far from her being a "machine-made doll" or "designed by a committee" she has a hands-on role in everything she does. They follow her lead.

She has chosen to be patron of charities in which she has a deep personal interest.

Kate, in the coming months and years, will let her actions speak for her.

Today she was back doing royal duties for her charity Action on Addiction at Hope House in Clapham, South London.

She looked fabulous as she stepped out of the royal car, happy to show her baby bump to the media gathered outside. She was well briefed and knew her stuff.

She is a beautiful, educated and stylish young woman, who has embraced her role with ease and injected much-needed glamour to the British royal family.

The Palace will step up the number of patronages in the coming months and claims that Kate is a plastic princess will soon fade.

Kate has her detractors -- many Internet trolls label her work shy -- but I am surprised someone of Mantel's stature has joined in this pastime, attacking Kate for no apparent reason.

In my view she has abused her position among the novel-writing elite to launch this astonishing attack on a woman half way through her pregnancy.

Mantel, whose latest books are set in the Tudor court, is lucky she is not a character in one of her own books. If she had attacked the wife of a future king back then with such vitriol she may have soon lost her head in a more literal sense.

Part of complete coverage on
Catherine, Duchess of Cambridge
updated 1:33 PM EST, Mon January 14, 2013
Media representatives gather in front of British artist Paul Emsley's portrait of Catherine, The Duchess of Cambridge after its unveiling at the National Portrait Gallery in central London on January 11, 2013.
The first official portrait of the Duchess of Cambridge has been unveiled - to a mixed reaction from art critics.
updated 5:43 PM EST, Mon January 7, 2013
British Vogue Deputy Editor Emily Sheffield talks to CNN about the Duchess of Cambridge's style and brand preferences.
updated 9:47 AM EDT, Tue June 25, 2013
Britain's Prince William and Catherine Middleton are expecting their first child after 19 months of marriage, the palace announced Monday.
updated 9:00 AM EST, Tue December 4, 2012
"A nation's joy, a husband's nerves," exclaimed the Daily Mail, contrasting William's anxious wait at his wife's bedside with exciting news.
updated 12:46 PM EST, Tue December 4, 2012
The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge are intensely private; they are also the most famous couple on the planet. This presents a dilemma.
updated 6:09 PM EST, Mon December 3, 2012
CNN's Atika Shubert reports hyperemesis gravidarum, the pregnancy-related medical condition the Duchess of Cambridge has.
updated 9:59 AM EDT, Tue June 25, 2013
CNN's Richard Quest explains how the birth of the baby the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge are expecting will affect the royal family.
updated 9:58 AM EDT, Tue June 25, 2013
The news that William and Catherine are expecting has positive implications for the future of the British monarchy, says Andrew Roberts.
updated 10:07 AM EDT, Tue June 25, 2013
Until 2011, any daughter born to the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge would not have enjoyed an equal right to inherit the British throne.
updated 9:50 AM EDT, Tue June 25, 2013
The Duchess of Cambridge - formerly known as Kate Middleton - is the daughter of self-made millionaires from rural England.
updated 7:39 AM EST, Wed November 21, 2012
Wherever she goes, the Duchess is surrounded by photographers. This time, she stayed behind the camera.
updated 1:34 PM EDT, Fri May 4, 2012
Has Britain's royal family learned from the legacy of Diana, Princess of Wales, as they protect Kate Middleton?
updated 1:34 PM EDT, Fri May 4, 2012
Every time Kate Middleton steps out in public, the fashion world pays attention. Whatever she wears is an instant hit.
updated 3:49 PM EDT, Mon March 19, 2012
The Duchess of Cambridge visits and formally opens The Treehouse, a children's hospice in Ipswich, England.
updated 12:28 PM EST, Mon January 9, 2012
Kate Middleton is surrounded by photographers as she leaves her flat in Chelsea, London, on her 25th birthday, January 9, 2007.
As the Duchess of Cambridge celebrates her 30th birthday, CNN takes a look back at her childhood and her royal romance.